navy chesterfield sofas

So I told y'all my sister's house is going to be insane.

And we all agreed her powder room wallpaper was sick.

Well, here is where we've left off with the front hall sitting area.

The walls are two shades of restoration hardware grey and the focal point is a big stone fireplace.  

There's a perfect little nook for a sitting area and she wants a navy velvet chesterfield sofa.

Lori helped her narrow it down to these two.

Oh so similar, yet oh so different, right.

well, oh so not the same couch anyway.

Which do you prefer?

#1 or #2

???