lamp shades

Okay, so here's al little corner of our dining room that I've been trying to overhaul lately.

Sorry for the crappy phone picture (not sure when I'll get around to taking a real picture)

Let's disregard the table skirt that very badly needs to be ironed, as well as the fact that it still needs some trim from when it lived in our entryway and we chatted about it here.

I'm waiting on lampshade decision to then tackle the trim.

 Okay, so here's where I need your help

Which lampshade do you like better?

Choices:

#1. Black and White Graphic Floral

#2. White (with black striped trim)

#3. Black (with white striped trim)

#4.  Something entirely different???  Do tell please!